Source: Yamada 2011

Yamada Keibun 山田恵文. "Shinran to Saihō shinan shō" 親鸞と『西方指南抄』. Shinran kyōgaku 親鸞教学 96 (2011): 21–37.

https://buddhism.lib.ntu.edu.tw/search/search_detail.jsp?seq=591997 https://otani.repo.nii.ac.jp/record/10262/files/SK096-03.pdf

Assertions

Assertion	Argument	Place in source	Search
Texts: T2674; 西方指南鈔	The Saihō shinan shō 西方指南抄 T2674 is an anonymous compilation of works attributed to the Japanese Pure Land patriarch Hōnen 法然. A manuscript of this work written by the Jōdo Shinshū patriarch Shinran 親鸞 is extant (National Treasure of Japan no. 176 https://kunishitei.bunka.go.jp/heritage/detail/201/695). The Taishō Tripiṭaka does not provide any attribution, nor does the Jōdoshū daijiten 浄土宗大辞典 (https://jodoshuzensho.jp/daijiten/index.php/%E8%A5%BF%E6%96%B9%E6%8C%87%E5%8D%97%E6%8A%84 ). Yamada reports on several different theories about the compilation process and ascription of T2674. Asano supports the theory that the text was compiled by Shinran, arguing that T2674 was originally conceived as three volumes, but that Shinran later divided each volume into a main 本 volume and a secondary 末 volume. Nakano supports the theory that the text was merely transcribed by Shinran, but not actually compiled by him, arguing that the original text was originally in six volumes; Nakano and speculates on the circumstances at the time of transcription by closely examining the colophon, red ink and cover, internal title 内題, and end title 尾題 of each volume. Works cited: Asano Kyōshin 浅野教信. "Saihō shinan shō no kenkyū josetsu" 西方指南抄の研究序説. Ryūkoku daigaku Bukkyō bunka kenkyūjo kiyō 龍谷大学仏教文化研究所紀要 3 (1964). Asano Kyōshin 浅野教信 Shinran Shōnin “Saihō shinan shō” no kenkyū 親鸞聖人『西方指南抄』の研究, vol. 1 上巻. Nagata bunshōdō 永田文昌堂, 1987. Nakano Masaaki 中野正明. "Saihō shinan shō no seiritsu ni tsuite" 『西方指南抄』の成立について. Sankō bunka kenkyūjo nenpō 三康文化研究所年報 22 (1990). Hiramatsu Reizō 平松令三 and Nakano Masaaki 中野正明. "Supplementary notes" 補記・補説, in vol. 6 of Zōho Shinran Shōnin shinseki shūsei 増補親鸞聖人真蹟集成. Hōzōkan 法蔵館, 2005. Edit		The Saiho shinan sho 西方指南抄 T2674 is an anonymous compilation of works attributed to the Japanese Pure Land patriarch Honen 法然. A manuscript of this work written by the Jodo Shinshu patriarch Shinran 親鸞 is extant (National Treasure of Japan no. 176 https://kunishitei.bunka.go.jp/heritage/detail/201/695). The Taisho Tripitaka does not provide any attribution, nor does the Jodoshu daijiten 浄土宗大辞典 (https://jodoshuzensho.jp/daijiten/index.php/%E8%A5%BF%E6%96%B9%E6%8C%87%E5%8D%97%E6%8A%84 ). Yamada reports on several different theories about the compilation process and ascription of T2674. Asano supports the theory that the text was compiled by Shinran, arguing that T2674 was originally conceived as three volumes, but that Shinran later divided each volume into a main 本 volume and a secondary 末 volume. Nakano supports the theory that the text was merely transcribed by Shinran, but not actually compiled by him, arguing that the original text was originally in six volumes; Nakano and speculates on the circumstances at the time of transcription by closely examining the colophon, red ink and cover, internal title 内題, and end title 尾題 of each volume. Works cited: Asano Kyoshin 浅野教信. "Saiho shinan sho no kenkyu josetsu" 西方指南抄の研究序説. Ryukoku daigaku Bukkyo bunka kenkyujo kiyo 龍谷大学仏教文化研究所紀要 3 (1964). Asano Kyoshin 浅野教信 Shinran Shonin “Saiho shinan sho” no kenkyu 親鸞聖人『西方指南抄』の研究, vol. 1 上巻. Nagata bunshodo 永田文昌堂, 1987. Nakano Masaaki 中野正明. "Saiho shinan sho no seiritsu ni tsuite" 『西方指南抄』の成立について. Sanko bunka kenkyujo nenpo 三康文化研究所年報 22 (1990). Hiramatsu Reizo 平松令三 and Nakano Masaaki 中野正明. "Supplementary notes" 補記・補説, in vol. 6 of Zoho Shinran Shonin shinseki shusei 増補親鸞聖人真蹟集成. Hozokan 法蔵館, 2005. T2674; 西方指南鈔

Assertion

Argument

Place in source

Texts: T2674; 西方指南鈔

The Saihō shinan shō 西方指南抄 T2674 is an anonymous compilation of works attributed to the Japanese Pure Land patriarch Hōnen 法然. A manuscript of this work written by the Jōdo Shinshū patriarch Shinran 親鸞 is extant (National Treasure of Japan no. 176 https://kunishitei.bunka.go.jp/heritage/detail/201/695). The Taishō Tripiṭaka does not provide any attribution, nor does the Jōdoshū daijiten 浄土宗大辞典 (https://jodoshuzensho.jp/daijiten/index.php/%E8%A5%BF%E6%96%B9%E6%8C%87%E5%8D%97%E6%8A%84 ).

Yamada reports on several different theories about the compilation process and ascription of T2674. Asano supports the theory that the text was compiled by Shinran, arguing that T2674 was originally conceived as three volumes, but that Shinran later divided each volume into a main 本 volume and a secondary 末 volume. Nakano supports the theory that the text was merely transcribed by Shinran, but not actually compiled by him, arguing that the original text was originally in six volumes; Nakano and speculates on the circumstances at the time of transcription by closely examining the colophon, red ink and cover, internal title 内題, and end title 尾題 of each volume.

Works cited:

Asano Kyōshin 浅野教信. "Saihō shinan shō no kenkyū josetsu" 西方指南抄の研究序説. Ryūkoku daigaku Bukkyō bunka kenkyūjo kiyō 龍谷大学仏教文化研究所紀要 3 (1964).

Asano Kyōshin 浅野教信 Shinran Shōnin “Saihō shinan shō” no kenkyū 親鸞聖人『西方指南抄』の研究, vol. 1 上巻. Nagata bunshōdō 永田文昌堂, 1987.

Nakano Masaaki 中野正明. "Saihō shinan shō no seiritsu ni tsuite" 『西方指南抄』の成立について. Sankō bunka kenkyūjo nenpō 三康文化研究所年報 22 (1990).

Hiramatsu Reizō 平松令三 and Nakano Masaaki 中野正明. "Supplementary notes" 補記・補説, in vol. 6 of Zōho Shinran Shōnin shinseki shūsei 増補親鸞聖人真蹟集成. Hōzōkan 法蔵館, 2005.

Edit